Five Sound View Properties Sold At Foreclosure Auction

Five properties in Old Lyme, including the former dance hall and two retail spaces on Hartford Avenue and two vacant lots, were auctioned off to the highest bidders on February 16.


It's not often that five properties just half a block from Sound View beach in Old Lyme go on the market at the same time and for bargain basement prices. So it's not surprising that a recent foreclosure auction (SI Realty Company Inc. v. Hartford Avenue 49-54 LLC et al) attracted a lot of attention from interested buyers.

The buildings included the historic dance hall and two retail spaces on Hartford Avenue that had been vacant for some time. At least a couple of the buildings had deteriorated to the point that many local residents had come to view them as blighted.  

The auction was originally scheduled to take place in December 2012, but had been postponed twice per order of the court. It was finally held on February 16. Attorney Matthew Berger, who was handling the foreclosure auction, said the property that attracted the most bidders was the vacant lot that had been used as a parking lot. 

The Properties: Going, Going, Gone!

  • 50 Hartford Avenue: vacant land (.22 acres), appraised at $79,900, sold for $76,000. The high bidder was Gail Fuller of 35 Anthony Drive, Bristol, who put down a deposit of $10,100. 
  • 52 Hartford Avenue: A one-storey, 3,148 square foot brick building constructed in 1936 on .21 aces, appraised at $211,400, sold for $105,000. The high bidder was William Randazzo of 40 Sea Spray Road, Old Lyme, who put down a deposit of $21,800.  
  • 56 Hartford Avenue: A 2,045 square foot, two-storey building with retail space on the first floor and an apartment on the second floor constructed in 1932 on .08 acres was appraised at $236,600. In that case, the plaintiff had the high bid of $75,000. 
  • 58 Hartford Avenue: This 8,431 square foot wooden building on .23 acres was originally built in 1931 as a dance hall. Most recently, it was used as retail space for antiques. It's currently appraised at $181,000. The high bidder was Frank Noe of 3 Atwater Terrace, Farmington, with a bid of $110,000 and a deposit of $7,900.  
  • 59 Swan Avenue: vacant land, .13 acres, appraised at $69,100. Again the high bidder was Frank Noe of 3 Atwater Terrace, Farmington with a bid of $66,000 and a deposit of $4,500. 

The sales aren't yet final, Berger said, because foreclosure sales have to be approved by the court and that won't happen until all associated costs and fees have been paid.

The court mandates that closings be held at least 21 days after the sale has been approved but not later than 30 days after. Although the court has discretion to accept or reject a sale, Berger said typically sales are approved. 

f.mags February 25, 2013 at 07:25 PM
Nobody owns these homes anyway. You can sell them ten times. The only way you can own a home these days if you clear the title.Mers is on every mortgage in the usa. Nobody owns any home in the usa.All homes in the usa we're paid off multiple times.When is everybody going to understand. When. Americans are to dumb to understand.
f.mags February 25, 2013 at 07:33 PM
If you believe anything else the government or the banks are saying it's just a big cover up to the biggest ponzi scheme in history
f.mags February 25, 2013 at 07:42 PM
Like the commercials on tv oh Wells Fargo can make you a homeowner.Sure even before you sign your closing documents your loan is being sold to hundreds of investors all over the world and then all your closing documents get destroyed. Yea just turn away from it and go put somebody in jail for stealing a piece of bubble gum.
Thomas Thatcher February 27, 2013 at 01:27 AM
I heard the old el maracco is being built up as a family restaurant now.. that building is beautiful! When they are done with it I can see that attracting alot of people back into the area for some quality dining! that would be nice to have around here! :)


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something